Sorry for the somewhat late response, but I wanted to thank ya'll for the advice. I had a bit of a bad injury myself (fell down a flight of stairs while skateboarding. Dumb, I know.) but I have problems with my upper back now.
While I have insurance, I'm still extremely picky about who I go to. If I'm going to see any number of specialists, I want my "time investment" to be worth it. If they can help me, then great!
Now, you mention physical/sports therapists as being the best option. What about other specialists like neurologists or chiropractors? Never know until ya try, right? Anyway, thanks a bunch!