1000Pks wrote:
Please, wilderness has no defense left here. I've seen snowmobile tracks high on Pyramid Peak (9,987') and elsewhere, courtesy, USFS. Don't ruin it forever.
Lets not confuse two different issues. The Desolation Wilderness boundary extends well below Pyramid on all sides, and there's absolutely no excuse for "accidentally" riding into it. People poaching wilderness areas and closed zones deserve to be cited (not that its much of a deterrent . . . I think the max fine is $1000, which given the odds of getting caught, is a joke). I've spent a lot of time in Desolation and have no desire to see it overrun with motorized vehicles.
It's true that you can get anywhere you want in the Sierra on skis, but that's equally true in the summer. Should we permanently close 4, 108, 120, and the massive network of approach roads that are closed in the wintertime? It would certainly preserve the wilderness better, and anyone with enough time and motivation could still hike in to Tuolumne Meadows or Sonora Pass. Climber traffic on Cathedral Peak would certainly drop off.
If you think that snowmobiles should be banned from the state, then I can respect that, although I don't agree. But don't equate legal snowmobile usage - which is actually pretty heavily restricted in popular areas - with highmarking inside a wilderness area.
Excuse me, I have been a wilderness user and supporter most all of my life, much due to the old time Sierra Club. There are venues for everything, this is a free country. Just that even with the MLC SC riddance of us, that doesn't change my mind about motorized vehicles on de facto wilderness. I'm sure if you go do it, you'll have a great fun time. There are millions of snowmobile enthusiasts though mainly in the NE. They will do as they please, it sure helps their economies.
Aside from maybe once or twice, I've never seen bc skiers towed by snowmobiles. I used to do a lot of winter bc, and we all mostly do not want such further intrusions where we all have skied and played.
There is a good legitimate reason for snow enabled transport, people like it and I've seen cross country skiers even rescued by them. Not me or anyone I know, though. And the Sierra Club I heard has its own fleet of snowmobiles, they run their lodge by Donner Pass, replete with a rope tow, last I saw. I just abhor the advancement into de facto wilderness, as those are the only places left locally in which you still can enjoy natural scenic beauty plus the quiet and peace of the mountains. That snowmobiles now run amuck on what I used to ski and enjoy, now, well I guess that's progress by some.
Myself, I haven't bc skied for years, and I surmise in another concession to big oil and all, the MLC SC got rid of all of us. But I'd love to get back into it, as I head into deep wilderness, and would not like it if a snowmobile, or presumably hundreds of them, should buzz about spoiling the peace and tranquility that so many of us once enjoyed. No big offense meant, just my 2 cents.