I have the skyledge. I love it. Have taken it car camping, overnight climbing trips (e.g. Capitol Peak), backpacking, and up Orizaba last Feb. Pros: Love the double doors, easy setup and light weight. Cons: I could see the length being a bit of an issue for taller people (works for me, I'm 5'11"). Also a bit snug for two, but with the pretty roomy vestibules it isn't too bad. In bad weather I'd make sure you were with a good friend. Could get a bit cold in there with the virtually all-mesh canopy. I have to repair one of the door zippers, but I think that one was my fault, not that of the tent. MH is repairing it for free. You'll need some beefier tent stakes, too.
Overall, very happy.