Re: Changes to Voting (Opinions Please)
Posted: Thu Jan 09, 2014 5:48 pm
yup
here's my contribution for the dark days ahead...
here's my contribution for the dark days ahead...
Climbing, hiking, mountaineering forum
http://www.summitpost.org/phpBB3/
https://www.summitpost.org/phpBB3/changes-to-voting-t66865-105.html
5 stars is easier than 10/10
Scott wrote:
Although there is some good stuff there, Mountain Project seems to have poor quality control and a lot of bad pages (at least in the areas I frequent, such as southern Utah). As in a huge percentage. There doesn't seem to be much quality control there, but I don't use it that often. From a quality standpoint, I'd hate to see SP go the way of Mountain Project.
On Mountainproject, if you see issues, how about you send an email to the area/route owner with CC to the area admin?
Luc wrote:If I want technical rockclimbing info I'll go to MP, no second thoughts.
For peaks and alpine routes SP has a lot of detailed beta not found elsewhere.
Buz Groshong wrote:We really should restrict it to photos that are attached to objects.
Scott wrote:it may be able to be hidden (Josh can tune in on this).
Josh Lewis wrote:Regarding MountainProject. They allow quality to fall pretty low, Mount Baker could be so much better. SP wouldn't put up with this.
Luc wrote:SP should produce offline viewable condensed route data, including topo overview. Because of the iPhone, it should probably be an application since I don't think pdfs can be saved and viewed away from coverage.
Luc wrote:...SP should produce offline viewable condensed route data, including topo overview. Because of the iPhone, it should probably be an application since I don't think pdfs can be saved and viewed away from coverage.