Welcome to SP!  -

User Profile Image

 
[ Sizes: Orig | Small | Thumb ]
User Profile Image
hispar pass

Comments


[ Post a Comment ]
Viewing: 1-14 of 14    

Karrar HaidriGreat Capture

Karrar Haidri

Voted 10/10

Rizwan,Thanks for sharing such a Nice Picture!Cheers.
Posted Dec 8, 2010 9:05 am

rizwanRe: Photoshop?

rizwan

Hasn't voted

my dear this shoot taken with the film cammera (slide film velvia iso 50)this is multiple exposure first i expose the moon with 200mm tele lens than overlap the whole frame with 19mm lens .thare is no phroshop tecnique adopted on this image,remmber this is 100% original photo.
thanks.
rizwan saddique
Posted Dec 9, 2010 6:30 am

MarcsoltanRe: Photoshop?

Marcsoltan

Hasn't voted

Okay, so you exposed your film slide to the Moon separately. The point is that the Moon was in a different location in the sky and not in this frame. This would have been a shot without the Moon.

Posted Dec 10, 2010 9:36 am

rizwanRe: Photoshop?

rizwan

Hasn't voted

yes moon is out of frame this is right behind of me. second shoot is without of moon,but after devolopment of slide this is single shoot with moon and landscpae of hispar pass.
Posted Dec 10, 2010 12:18 pm

MarcsoltanRe: Photoshop?

Marcsoltan

Hasn't voted

Well, that was my point to begin with. The Moon does not belong in this photo. It doesn't matter if you use photoshop to add something to scene, or if you expose the film twice in different locations. I personally like to see photos that are real, not manufactured using different techniques.

Respectfully,
Marc Soltan
Posted Dec 10, 2010 12:26 pm

rizwanRe: Photoshop?

rizwan

Hasn't voted

no my dear friend this moon does belong in photo( next input of my is original slide)this is better for understanding this picture tecnique
Posted Dec 10, 2010 1:11 pm

MarcsoltanRe: Photoshop?

Marcsoltan

Hasn't voted

Okay, we can go back and forth on this forever.
Here is one simple question, was the Moon there,above the Hispar Pass, in that exact same spot, when you took this shot? Or, as you put it, it was behind you?
Posted Dec 10, 2010 1:58 pm

mrchad9Re: Photoshop?

mrchad9

Hasn't voted

My guess from the shadows on the snow would be behind the right shoulder somewhere. Hard to say without seeing the full resolution.
Posted Dec 10, 2010 2:56 pm

SoCalHikerC'mon

SoCalHiker

Voted 10/10

There is nothing wrong with that technique. Many gorgeous photos published in various outdoor magazines or available for purchase are collages. In my opinion, it's in the "artist's" discretion to enhance the scene to the point where it conveys his or her view. Most incredible photos in Outdoors magazines are HDR photography which are all processed, superimposed images.
Posted Dec 10, 2010 3:28 pm

MarcsoltanRe: C'mon

Marcsoltan

Hasn't voted

Well Guido, then I guess I'll have to chalk this up to the matter of opinion. If you like this technique, then I have no doubt you will love the photo that is about to become POTW. In that one the photographer has taken a few artistic liberties as well. Who am I to judge!
Posted Dec 10, 2010 3:56 pm

SoCalHikerRe: C'mon

SoCalHiker

Voted 10/10

Marc, of course everybody is entitled to his or her opinion and liking of that "technique". I know many who don't like it. I am merely saying that it is common practice and taught in photography classes/workshops and books from professionals.
Posted Dec 10, 2010 4:18 pm

MarcsoltanRe: C'mon

Marcsoltan

Hasn't voted

Point well taken, Guido.
:-)
Posted Dec 10, 2010 4:23 pm

Lubosfrom lubos

Lubos

Voted 10/10

Hi, your picture looks even better. I hope to get to Pakistan in 2013.
Greetings
Posted Feb 10, 2011 1:50 pm

Josh LewisI like it!

Josh Lewis

Voted 10/10

I know exactly how the author feels, even if the moon was a ways to the side. If the photo were then zoomed out you loose a lot of the subject, plus if they were out on a expedition they need to get some good rest rather than staying up all night just so it would be in that one spot. This photo wins my respect. Thanks for sharing.
Cheers Josh Lewis.
Posted Feb 12, 2011 10:40 pm

Viewing: 1-14 of 14    




Rate This Image
Current Score: 95.51

Log In To Vote
[ View 53 Votes | Post Comment ]  
Image Data
rizwanSubmitted by rizwan
on Dec 8, 2010 8:56 am

Image ID: 683592
Hits: 1578 
Object Title: User Profile Image