Vitaliy M wrote:I asked several people about it (even people who completed it), but no one seem to have the answer.
What qualifies a Sierra peak to be on SPS list?

Every Sierra peak the Sierra Club (SPS section) deems worthwhile... meaning it's subjective

I don't think it actually has strict, objective criteria for putting it on the list, but I might stand corrected

Here's the history of the SPS list, for those interested.

If you think the SPS list is arbitrary then go look at the OGUL list.

Mt Fillmore? Seriously?

fedak wrote:If you think the SPS list is arbitrary then go look at the OGUL list.

Mt Fillmore? Seriously?

Hey! I just hiked that Wednesday! Cool viewpoint, actually, not a terrible hike . . . but it was less than a mile, too

Dougb wrote:The SPS list is essentially closed.

Not true. They added Caltech in 2008.

Don't get started, Vitaliy! There are other things you can do with your life!

1000Pks wrote:I wrote up the 1985 Peak and Gorge list for them, the Northern Alpine Section List, however now stolen

You should have made a photocopy.

1000Pks wrote:

mrchad9 wrote:

1000Pks wrote:I wrote up the 1985 Peak and Gorge list for them, the Northern Alpine Section List, however now stolen

You should have made a photocopy.

We did, 100 of them. Never heard how they sold, maybe they threw them all away. You could just talk to me to have a peak put on that list, we had a public comment period.

Then apparently it was not stolen.

Vitaliy M wrote:

Diggler wrote:Don't get started, Vitaliy! There are other things you can do with your life!

Comming from a guy who does CA county high points : )))))

That's exactly why! There have been many a CoHP where I've thought 'Now why am I not actually climbing this weekend???!!!' I'm just in too deep now...

1000Pks wrote:

mrchad9 wrote:

1000Pks wrote:

mrchad9 wrote:

1000Pks wrote:I wrote up the 1985 Peak and Gorge list for them, the Northern Alpine Section List, however now stolen

You should have made a photocopy.

We did, 100 of them. Never heard how they sold, maybe they threw them all away. You could just talk to me to have a peak put on that list, we had a public comment period.

Then apparently it was not stolen.

Copyright infringement. It appears unauthorized (by me) at several websites. All that research and climbing, and I never even get credit!

If you wrote it for them, then it would seem you are not the holder of the copywrite.

Assuming a list can be copywrited, which it cannot.