I posted a nearly identical one.
Aha! The redundant photo can of worms, and a particularily sticky case here. We are well into the realm of subjective, but the bigdan photo is a better portrait of the peak, while the Kid's is a more pleasing composition, with that foreground break in trees adding hugely to the overall scene. Both 4-star shots.
IMHO, of course.
Oops, didn't see that one Dan. I think I may leave it though, because as Don pointed out, yours is an excellent close-up, but mine adds (what word did he use?) composition with the trees.
Agh, I meant Nelson, not Don.
There is a Don Nelsen around here! :-)
I was just commenting that our cameras performed similar... Mine is a closer shot, yours gives more an idea of the terrain. Leave em both up :-)