Do not get offended. I am very demanding person, even with myself !!! Do not tell to anybody but I would not give a four stars vote to my own page!!! ;-) I think that the four stars system of SP is, in general, a little bit used in a 'happy' or 'easy' way, sometimes superficial: "I like this page! Ok, yes. 4 stars!!! I do not like it. I do not vote it".
I think that we see too many "4 stars" mountain pages. Maybe it is time to start a 5 stars rating to be able to judge more accurately. I just was judging a page of Johan Heersink (the Kingata Tagh mountain page) as, definitely a '5 stars' page in a message send to him.If I compare my page with his, mine is definitely just a 3!!!
I like your page of Mount Helen very much (and I have been reading it with interest). Nice maps and worked route-sketches. Also nice links to neighbour ranges and peaks, but I would have liked a little bit more detail over the Father Dyer's rock ridge. Useful links to other souces of information...I would say your pagina is a 3 and a half (or a 'four' in a five stars ranking) and mine is a 2... :-)
I hope, anyway, to go sometimes to the Rockies and then, when I climb Mount Hellen I will think of you.
Well, I'm not offended, but I just don't understand what you mean. If you see it as a 3 star page, then you should have a list of improvements that need to be made. What would I have to add to make it 4 stars for you?
16 other long-time members voted 4 stars on the page. You're entitled to your opinion, of course, but it seems like you're in the minority with your vote.
Grant - May 24, 2005 1:31 pm - Voted 10/10
Untitled CommentNice.
Ed F - May 25, 2005 9:20 am - Hasn't voted
Untitled CommentThanks
mdavenport2 - May 24, 2005 6:24 pm - Voted 10/10
Untitled CommentNice page. Thanks for recognizing this oft-ignored peak.
Ed F - May 25, 2005 9:19 am - Hasn't voted
Untitled CommentThanks for the vote. It's a great mountain.
Ed F - May 25, 2005 9:21 am - Hasn't voted
Untitled CommentThanks for the vote
John Climber - Aug 14, 2005 2:14 pm - Voted 8/10
Untitled CommentShort and clear, as the mountain seems to require.
Ed F - Aug 14, 2005 2:17 pm - Hasn't voted
Untitled CommentWhy the 3 star vote? I'm curious as to what more needs to be added to this page to improve it?
Thanks,
ed
John Climber - Aug 14, 2005 4:34 pm - Voted 8/10
Untitled CommentSisyphus,
Do not get offended. I am very demanding person, even with myself !!! Do not tell to anybody but I would not give a four stars vote to my own page!!! ;-) I think that the four stars system of SP is, in general, a little bit used in a 'happy' or 'easy' way, sometimes superficial: "I like this page! Ok, yes. 4 stars!!! I do not like it. I do not vote it".
I think that we see too many "4 stars" mountain pages. Maybe it is time to start a 5 stars rating to be able to judge more accurately. I just was judging a page of Johan Heersink (the Kingata Tagh mountain page) as, definitely a '5 stars' page in a message send to him.If I compare my page with his, mine is definitely just a 3!!!
I like your page of Mount Helen very much (and I have been reading it with interest). Nice maps and worked route-sketches. Also nice links to neighbour ranges and peaks, but I would have liked a little bit more detail over the Father Dyer's rock ridge. Useful links to other souces of information...I would say your pagina is a 3 and a half (or a 'four' in a five stars ranking) and mine is a 2... :-)
I hope, anyway, to go sometimes to the Rockies and then, when I climb Mount Hellen I will think of you.
Greetings
Ed F - Aug 15, 2005 11:33 am - Hasn't voted
Untitled CommentWell, I'm not offended, but I just don't understand what you mean. If you see it as a 3 star page, then you should have a list of improvements that need to be made. What would I have to add to make it 4 stars for you?
16 other long-time members voted 4 stars on the page. You're entitled to your opinion, of course, but it seems like you're in the minority with your vote.
mmoerk - Oct 7, 2005 7:57 pm - Voted 10/10
Untitled CommentMore excellent information.
Ed F - Oct 8, 2005 10:48 am - Hasn't voted
Untitled CommentThanks for checking it out and voting.