I sent you that email before I realized you were posting the route on SP. I can wait until you finish the page ;-) Is this the same route Roach call "The North Buttress"?
i'm not familiar with any of roach's books, so i can't really answer that question. i would assume its the same route though. i got my info from Climbing Colorado's San Juan Mountains and from the FA description in the CMC's Trail and Timberline.
Cool. I've read the Trail and Timberline description and that seems to be the same thing Roach describes.
Not sure what your deal is with routes needing to be detailed to death. Not my style. I put enough on to entice...but keep the adventure alive.
it was more like 2 minutes...I'm good with that.
I agree with the need to have more information. Looks like the page was lazily/hastily thrown together. If this is not your style, perhaps allow others to adopt page for the purposes of creating a more informative/descriptive one. This is the general trend of SP route pages. It is also what people looking to research a route would like to see (if we wanted adventure, we wouldn't look).
May I also recommend accepting criticism rather than rebuking the comments of others. These will only make your page better- an ego will only make it (and yourself) look worse.
I agree with the criticism here. This page is not executed very well. It does not meet the typical standard of SP pages. I am very interested in this route and the information you have provided here is barely more than I could have got from a topo map. I dont think this is the point of SP. If you are proud of the incompleteness of this page, as you seem to be, I suggest you dont post routes here anymore.
I also agree with the criticism. The page hardly has any info in it.