by simonov » Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:05 pm
by Kurt Wedberg » Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:29 pm
by jonclimbingon » Wed Nov 18, 2009 6:55 pm
by justing » Wed Nov 18, 2009 10:56 pm
Gary Schenk wrote:I've taken a couple of wilderness first aid courses. I learned two things:
1. Don't get hurt in the wilderness.
2. I now know why you're going to die, I just can't do anything about it.
by alleyehave » Thu Nov 19, 2009 12:58 am
justing wrote:Gary Schenk wrote:I've taken a couple of wilderness first aid courses. I learned two things:
1. Don't get hurt in the wilderness.
2. I now know why you're going to die, I just can't do anything about it.
Last month I took a two day wilderness first aid class in Santa Cruz from WMI. I think the above sentiment is true to a certain extent, but I still found the class very useful. It's difficult in such a short class to spend much time on how to treat stuff -- I feel like I could use more practice on how to deal with a broken limb or dislocated finger for instance. Also, if you want CPR it's not covered. The primary benefit is knowing the basics of evaluating and stabilizing the patient and making good decisions. I also think a bit of training is useful in keeping your head in a stressful situation.
To the OP - PM me if you want to know the full syllabus.[/i]
by justing » Thu Nov 19, 2009 1:36 am
alleyehave wrote:justing wrote:Gary Schenk wrote:I've taken a couple of wilderness first aid courses. I learned two things:
1. Don't get hurt in the wilderness.
2. I now know why you're going to die, I just can't do anything about it.
Last month I took a two day wilderness first aid class in Santa Cruz from WMI. I think the above sentiment is true to a certain extent, but I still found the class very useful. It's difficult in such a short class to spend much time on how to treat stuff -- I feel like I could use more practice on how to deal with a broken limb or dislocated finger for instance. Also, if you want CPR it's not covered. The primary benefit is knowing the basics of evaluating and stabilizing the patient and making good decisions. I also think a bit of training is useful in keeping your head in a stressful situation.
To the OP - PM me if you want to know the full syllabus.[/i]
Trust me, good decision making is an intrinsic skill, not one that can be taught.
Deal with a broken limb? Attach something rigid.
Dislocated bone? Splint in place, or if necessary retract with force and allow it to settle naturally.
2 day wilderness FA class, complete.
by alleyehave » Thu Nov 19, 2009 1:50 am
justing wrote:alleyehave wrote:justing wrote:Gary Schenk wrote:I've taken a couple of wilderness first aid courses. I learned two things:
1. Don't get hurt in the wilderness.
2. I now know why you're going to die, I just can't do anything about it.
Last month I took a two day wilderness first aid class in Santa Cruz from WMI. I think the above sentiment is true to a certain extent, but I still found the class very useful. It's difficult in such a short class to spend much time on how to treat stuff -- I feel like I could use more practice on how to deal with a broken limb or dislocated finger for instance. Also, if you want CPR it's not covered. The primary benefit is knowing the basics of evaluating and stabilizing the patient and making good decisions. I also think a bit of training is useful in keeping your head in a stressful situation.
To the OP - PM me if you want to know the full syllabus.[/i]
Trust me, good decision making is an intrinsic skill, not one that can be taught.
Deal with a broken limb? Attach something rigid.
Dislocated bone? Splint in place, or if necessary retract with force and allow it to settle naturally.
2 day wilderness FA class, complete.
True, but sometimes you need information to make a decision, unless you're George W. Bush. What information? How to interpret that information? I admit to not knowing the answers to those questions, and I found the course useful for that.
And I hope no one actually thinks this is all you need to know to put a dislocated joint back in place. You could seriously f--- someone's shoulder up if done improperly. I also found useful some of the nuances to improvising a splint for a broken bone useful. Stuff I wouldn't have thought of like putting something behind the knee to keep it from locking, or that you should try to realign the broken bone if possible. If you already knew about that stuff then good for you.
by radson » Thu Nov 19, 2009 2:50 am
by alleyehave » Thu Nov 19, 2009 5:48 am
radson wrote:Personally I found the WFR course, very interesting and not just common sense as some people allude. Not only fractures and disclocations of course, asthma, diabetes, environmental injuries etc.
by cbcbd » Thu Nov 19, 2009 7:25 am
alleyehave wrote:radson wrote:Personally I found the WFR course, very interesting and not just common sense as some people allude. Not only fractures and disclocations of course, asthma, diabetes, environmental injuries etc.
I'm not sure how you properly treat asthma, or even real diabetic emergencies in the wilderness without o2/breathing treatment, d50/iv, or glucagon for that matter...but more power to ya...
by radson » Thu Nov 19, 2009 12:16 pm
alleyehave wrote:radson wrote:Personally I found the WFR course, very interesting and not just common sense as some people allude. Not only fractures and disclocations of course, asthma, diabetes, environmental injuries etc.
I'm not sure how you properly treat asthma, or even real diabetic emergencies in the wilderness without o2/breathing treatment, d50/iv, or glucagon for that matter...but more power to ya...
by alleyehave » Thu Nov 19, 2009 3:58 pm
radson wrote:alleyehave wrote:radson wrote:Personally I found the WFR course, very interesting and not just common sense as some people allude. Not only fractures and disclocations of course, asthma, diabetes, environmental injuries etc.
I'm not sure how you properly treat asthma, or even real diabetic emergencies in the wilderness without o2/breathing treatment, d50/iv, or glucagon for that matter...but more power to ya...
So whats your recommendation alleyhave? to remain as ignorant as possible?
by simonov » Thu Nov 19, 2009 7:29 pm
alleyehave wrote:I'm not dogging on the programs, but to assume you can adequately treat these issues in the backcountry is misleading and an unsafe attitude.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests