Scared on Ship Rock

Scared on Ship Rock

Page Type Page Type: Trip Report
Date Date Climbed/Hiked: Nov 27, 2010

Trouble Before We Arrive

The trip started smoothly enough. Franky scooped me up at McCarran International and we made our way east into Arizona and stopped for the night west of Flagstaff. We were a little concerned with how cold it was (8 degrees F at 7000 feet) but knew that there was a slight warming trend predicted for Saturday before the weather went to hell again. We decided heading northeast through the Navajo Reservation would be a more interesting drive than staying on I-40 to get to New Mexico, so we turned off at Flagstaff, grabbed some groceries, and made our way onto the Reservation.

Taking the scenic route almost ended up costing us the trip. Little did we know that our first encounter with the Navajo Tribal Police would be 100 miles from Ship Rock. As Franky was coming down a hill at a rate of speed greater than or equal to the speed limit, an SUV headed in the opposite direction swung a U-turn and sped up to pull us over. Franky, ever the dirtbag, began pleading with the officer to not give him the speeding ticket he couldn’t afford. The cop had Frank step out of the vehicle and patted him down.
Ship Rock from the North


“I live in my truck, I don’t have money to pay a ticket!” Franky insisted.
Ship Rock from the East
“Then why do you have an Illinois registration and a California driver’s license?” the officer retorted.

Franky launched into an elaborate story that he was borrowing his dad’s truck to drive back to Illinois in order to look for a job. He was apparently dropping me off in Boulder. I could hear the officer behind the car reciting seemingly the entire Schedule I Controlled Substances List and asking if Franky had any of each in the car. When Franky said no, he told Franky he had smelled weed and asked to search the truck, with which Franky told him he didn’t feel comfortable.
Ship Rock from the South


I’m glad he didn’t ask me where we were going because I didn’t know Franky had created this story until after they had me get out of the car and asked me which drugs I was carrying on me. He then brought out a dog to sniff the car. I assumed he’d have a German Shepherd in the car, but he pulled out a mangy mutt that I’m pretty sure he picked up that morning from the plethora of strays roaming the Reservation. The officer explained that if the dog pointed, it would constitute probable cause to search the vehicle. He trotted the dog for one lap around the car, and the dog didn’t seem to react in the slightest. When he finally got the dog all the way around the car, he jerked the dog’s leash tightly and the dog lurched up. Apparently this was his probable cause, and I’m pretty sure we had our rights under the 4th Amendment violated.
Ship Rock


As Franky and I stood and watched the officer, then the mutt, and then another officer who pulled over to join the party rifle through the car, I asked him if he thought he had any weed in the car. “I’m not sure, maybe.” Even hearing this, I wasn’t too worried about things until I realized the contraband that I had been carrying.

“Damn it!” I said. “I left the articles we printed out about climbing Ship Rock on the seat! And they’ll see our rack in the back!” Climbing has been outlawed on Spider Rock and the Totem Pole since 1962 and the entire Navajo Reservation following an accident on Ship Rock in 1970. Many clandestine ascents have occurred over the years, but there was nothing clandestine about our efforts so far.
Ship Rock Alpenglow


Franky was sure we’d end up in Navajo-Pound-Me-In-The-Ass prison for drugs, and I was sure we’d end up there for having climbing gear and information on Ship Rock. As it turned out, we were sent along on our merry way, unscathed. We voiced our concerns about the legality of the search to an Arizona State Trooper that pulled over to join the fun, he went and talked to the Navajo officers, and they let us go before they could find the weed the first cop was 100% sure he had smelled. We left a little leery of the police presence and got to Ship Rock just before the sun went down. Our little hour plus detour to the side of the highway had cost us any chance as reconnoitering the route. We saw a fantastic sunset, cooked some dinner, and tucked into our sleeping bags in the back of the truck for a long, cold night.

Climbing Ship Rock

We awoke to very cold temperatures outside and frost all over the inside of the truck. We decided that 800 fill down was more appealing than the arctic air outside and hunkered down until the sun hit the truck. This was barely enough to convince us to get up, eat a little breakfast, and start walking. We heated up pretty quickly as we climbed the talus to the base of the route. It starts with a very bouldery move from a pile of stacked blocks to a gear placement after the tricky climbing is done (of course). Some more scrambling led us to the base of the black bowl that we figured would be an easy section of the route.
First Pitch
Topp Memorial

Plaques in memoriam of fallen climbers are not my favorite way to inspire confidence before a climb, and Bernard E. Topp’s didn’t make me feel any better about the shattered wall of black basalt that lay ahead. I got a few bad pieces of gear in, put screamers on all of them, and still wasn’t very happy about this section of the climb. Franky wasn’t happy either when I nearly domed him with a baseball sized piece of basalt.
Franky
More Franky

“Sorry, the rope knocked that off!” I said in an effort to calm him down. He said some choice things about my routefinding ability before I found a couple of fixed pins and then followed these to a bolt anchor at the top of the steep section.
Snowy Traverse
Summit

From here we unroped and scrambled through the loose stuff to a flat spot where we restacked the ropes and simulclimbed up to what we think was Sierra Col. This section was covered in snow and was slippery in rock shoes. From the col we had a nice view of what we were pretty sure was the summit, as well as Longs Couloir, which we would follow for the descent. We traversed over to what we were pretty sure was Colorado Col and Franky led up a face of kitty litter to the top of the rappel gully.

I went first off of less than inspiring bolts (at least there were three of them!) and at the end of the 60m ropes found myself above an abyss on an ice covered slab. “Damn, I wish I had stopped and rapped off the single bolt above,” I told myself, but there was an overhanging chockstone that would be a lot of trouble to go back up and try to deal with to get to that anchor. Instead, I downclimbed to a single bolt on the face, clipped it, and told Franky to make two rappels to get to me. He did, and as we pulled the ropes on the rappel we didn’t need to mention what we both knew: we were committed to finishing the route, as the only reasonable chance of escape at this point was the rap route that allegedly began from the summit.
Col Belay

Awful Anchor

The Rappel

From here we began a couple of pitches of wild traversing. I am very impressed that David Brower did this in 1939, well before the advent of sticky rubber climbing shoes. Just finding this traverse was a masterpiece of routefinding and, combined with the rappel, was the key to the route. The ancient bolts on these pitches were less than ideal, and we were once again happy to have brought so many Screamers along.
Mega-Gnar Traverse


What we found after the traversing was rather horrifying. The pitches that were supposed to be 4th and easy 5th class slab climbing were swathed in a thin coat of snow. Knowing we were committed to the route at this point, I led up the first pitch of this heinousness. It was rather low angle, but slippery as all hell and above a giant cliff. A slip here would probably send me over the abyss. I moved slowly and when I was well past the halfway mark on the rope, decided it was high time to find an anchor, as this was not the place to be simulclimbing with no gear between us. “Frank…” I said, ready to call for him to tag up the hand drill and bolt kit we had brought along. But then I saw a white sling sticking out of the snow, and, like buried treasure, found a solid two bolt anchor attached to it.
Snowy BS
Franky  bout to sh*t himself

Franky had the unfortunate pleasure of leading the next pitch. Even belaying him, I was probably as scared as I’ve ever been climbing. It felt like I was feeding out a few feet of rope every 5 minutes, and as Frank neared the end of the rope I yelled “30 feet…20 feet…10 feet…5 feet!” Once again, this was NOT simulclimbing territory. Franky yelled down and asked me if I could simul 20 feet.

“Do you have any gear in?” I asked.

“No.”

“Then no!” I yelled back. I would have had to make a snow covered traverse across the steepest section of slab, and this was not a risk I was willing to take. “Drop the blue rope!” I yelled, and I tied both ropes together to belay him on one 120m half rope.

During this marathon pitch, I saw an 80s model black pickup truck hauling across the desert, kicking up a dust cloud and heading straight for us. I’m not sure if it was my pounding heartbeat, or just the truck smashing along the bumpy road, but I swear I heard the beating of a drum as it came closer.

[doom-doom][doom-doom][doom-doom][doom-doom]

I decided Franky had enough to worry about with what he was doing so I didn’t mention what I had seen and maybe heard. There are tales of smashed windows, slashed tires, and looted gear from past climbers of Ship Rock. At this point I didn’t care, all I wanted was to not have to catch a 700 foot slab slide off a cliff and for Franky to build an anchor and bring me up so we could finish this thing. Though this opinion was an easy one for me to take, seeing as it was Franky’s car, I’m pretty sure at this point he would have agreed with me. The shadow of Ship Rock was also creeping away from us across the desert floor 1500 feet below, a cruel reminder of the cold night that was about to befall us.

And then I heard those magical words: “Off belay!”

Franky took the rope up extra tight on me, and I was forced to climb up where I would have rather climbed down a bit to get into the lower angle section of the slab. I hoped he had a good anchor as I stepped across the slab, made a few moves, and then…

SNAP!

I began sliding down the snow after snapping a foothold. I went a long way on the single 120m half rope, and I briefly wondered if I had pulled Franky from his perch above as I hurtled toward the cliff below. The rope came taught with me maybe 20-30 feet further down from where I had started, my knuckles bloody, my shoes soaking wet, and me freezing cold. At least I knew I had a solid belay from above.

Apparently Franky wanted to make things more exciting for the both of us, because he missed this bomber three piece anchor less than one rope length above where he had started.
Apparently this anchor wasn t worth clipping


When I finally got up to him, he was drained, and I don’t blame him. He told me what I had already suspected: that this was the scariest pitch he’d ever climbed. Apparently I hadn’t even weighted his anchor with my fall, as he had a good stance. I can only imagine the fate we'd have met if I pulled him off his stance and down the slab.

One more 100 foot section of this heinous slab led to a short crack with probably the first solid gear placements I’d made all day. Atop this crack was the notch between the north and south summits, and I was greeted by the warm rays of the sun’s finale.
Franky Maxin  and Relaxin

Above us lay the crux of the route (in dry conditions), the Horn Pitch. A couple of bolts and a couple of pins protected crumbly face climbing with unbelievable exposure down the West Face. Once again I placed Screamers on everything, and even then I’m not sure any of these relics would have held a fall.
Horn Pitch

Franky led yet another photogenic traversing pitch and stopped just below the summit, leaving the glory pitch for me. I decided to find the rap anchors in the fading twilight before summiting, and after doing so belayed Frank to the top as the sky blazed red, the already-set sun illuminating the high clouds to the west. We had hoped to find the summit register, but it was nowhere to be found. It is allegedly elaborate and strewn with the names of quite the cast of climbers.
Traverse to Summit Block


Descent

The first four double rope rappels from the summit led to Longs Couloir. Within the first 50 feet I found a precariously perched VCR sized block, pulled up the ropes, and trundled it. Apparently Franky hadn’t heard my warning and screamed “Mike, are you OK?!?!!” from above. I told him not to worry and that I was just cleaning up the rap route for us. We touched down in the gully and made our way down, rapping every now and again and trundling whatever posed even the tiniest threat to us in the gully. At this point there was no way anyone within miles of the west side of Ship Rock wouldn’t know we were there, and with our headlamps already tipping them off, we figured a little extra noise wouldn’t increase the chances of our getting arrested. Trundling is also really fun, but everyone already knows that.

A little wandering in the desert led us to the completely intact car. Despite the late hour, we had already decided getting out of there that night was a good idea. We couldn’t be bothered to cook, so we stopped for some Burger King before heading back into Arizona.

Continually scary from start to finish, this route is poorly protected on poor rock. I don’t recommend climbing it if there is any snow in the upper bowl. There is nothing safe about climbing Ship Rock. Having said all of this, this is one of the most rewarding experiences I have ever had, and would wholeheartedly recommend this climb to anyone willing to take on the challenges it affords. Thanks again to Franky for climbing it with me!
Ship Rock Sunset 1/5
Ship Rock Sunset 2/5
Ship Rock Sunset 3/5
Ship Rock Sunset 4/5
Ship Rock Sunset 5/5


Comments

Post a Comment
Viewing: 21-40 of 66
Dmitry Pruss

Dmitry Pruss - Dec 6, 2010 12:15 am - Voted 10/10

SP is a wiki, not a federation

SP doesn't have rules of conduct or bylaws or somesuch stuff. Rather, it is a web community of people contributing to the common lore. The rules are strict in that respect, no stealing content, good style rules ... not with respect to the actual realspace conduct of the contributors.

I would let the one who never violated any rules when climbing "cast the first stone". My few front-page TRs were all about trips which fragrantly disregarded the rules ... so I won't

pearson - Dec 5, 2010 6:13 pm - Hasn't voted

History

If you want to read correct history of climbing the rock this is as good a place as any I've seen. Some of the history posted in the article contradicts what the Los Alamos Mountaineers wrote.

http://lamountaineers.org/History/Topic_6.html

m_dquist

m_dquist - Dec 5, 2010 7:17 pm - Hasn't voted

Re: History

Interesting article, and probably more reliable than drunks around a campfire (my usual source). Thanks.

Kiefer

Kiefer - Dec 5, 2010 10:13 pm - Voted 10/10

Mixed Feelings but...

overall I have to give ya guys major kudos for climbing this! What an unbelievable adventure/climb this must have been. I would have felt humbled to be folloowing in the footsteps & handholds of some major names who've previously been up this.

But also, I think I would have refrained from writing anything up and posting it publically. The lambasting this report is receiving seems to be about par for the course. Climbs like this tend to polarize the climbing community (obviously). I think simply posting some pictures would have done the climb enough justice whilst avoiding the negative comments.
But never-the-less, congrats on a sweet, kick-ass climb!

lcarreau

lcarreau - Dec 5, 2010 10:20 pm - Voted 1/10

Wonders for your Karma..

"The women, children and old men on the top
slowly starved to death, leaving their bodies
to settle there.

Therefore, because of this legend, the
Navajos do not want anyone to climb Shiprock
for fear of stirring up the ch'iidii, or rob
their corpses."

Woodie Hopper

Woodie Hopper - Dec 6, 2010 12:59 am - Voted 5/10

Ambivalent

I respect your right to climb this rock, but not to flaunt treading on the sensitivities of others. Great climb nonetheless. 5/10, can't have it both ways.

Klenke

Klenke - Dec 6, 2010 2:47 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Well

When the Frito Banditos climbed Ship Rock back in 2002 they reported that they had made "the 438th ascent of the mountain (in the 63 years since the first ascent) and only the 5th ascent this year.". 438 divided by 63 = 7 climbing parties per year making it to the top (not including the unknown number of other parties who don't make it so can't sign the register. Now, I totally understand this mountain can be and is sacred to the Navajo Nation, but if they were really serious about keeping people off of it they would be more proactive in that regard. There is no gate to keep you from driving right up to it. There are no No Trespassing signs anywhere. And there is no surveillance. There is no policing. Even when I was there a Navajo fellow conversed with me right underneath it and made no attempt to tell me I was trespassing or not welcome. Therefore, if they really cared that much, they would at least attempt some means of keeping climbers away. That's the reality on the ground. The quasi-reality of the Internet and those that laze on lounge chairs in their favorite cyberspace gossip salons is a completely different thing. And this is why it is not for you but for the Navajo to tell us (and show us) what they do and do not want us to do. It's their sanctuary. So let them be the ones to be sanctimonious.

Vicles

Vicles - Dec 6, 2010 1:55 am - Voted 10/10

Harding would have climbed it!

Integrity and respect are not synonymous.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrity

By the deff. of integrity, the OP's is only strenghened by spraying about his deeds, and standing behind them.

I want to point out that it's a Steck and Roper 50 Fucking Classic! What about respecting and honoring OUR history as climbers? What if El Cap was suddenly deemed "Jesus Mountain" and became offlimits? Would people still climb the Nose and post TR's about it? Of course. Because for many many climbers, the line, the history, the asthetics, and the movement trump politics, religion, etc. And Thank God for that. ;)

noahs213

noahs213 - Dec 6, 2010 2:08 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Harding would have climbed it!

Interesting to point out about the Totem Pole which along with Ship Rock is closed but even more closed since it's in the Tribal Loop. It's "sacred" but whenever alot of money is offered you can climb anywhere in the res it seems. Let's put Clint Eastwood on top, Hollywood Stars, IBM commercials, other commercials..etc. Very "not sacred" Ship Rock and Spider Rock are there most sacred summits though, but many have gotten permission from landowners quite easily. Not saying it's ok, just stating interesting points.

TR was a great inspiring read.

Vicles

Vicles - Dec 6, 2010 4:47 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Harding would have climbed it!

Nice. I would have just written; "Bullshit!" ;)

kamil

kamil - Dec 6, 2010 5:50 am - Voted 10/10

off-limit mountains

I somehow can't accept the concept of a mountain being off-limits to climbers. In most cases. And there are a few possible cases.
Most of all I can't agree with the concept of a 'private mountain'. For big landowners, common sense dictates that only their household, buildings and their immediate vicinity (curtilage? my legal English is limited) and cultivated land are obviously off limits. But forests, badlands, mountains being off limits to responsible ramblers? That's sick.
The right to roam is something basic to human nature. Of course with rights come responsibilities but I needn't mention such obvious things here.
The same with mountains being off limits for political reasons. I have no bones about illegally crossing political borders in the mountains.
Mountains in military areas - also something artificial to me. Play the game - climb and try not to get caught (or shot) if you dare, as far as your common sense allows.
Religion is a different ballgame. I have deep respect for religions, beliefs, faiths, whichever denomination. I would perhaps still try to climb a mountain, but... see below.
Environmental protection - another thing too. Some mountains or routes are off limits in particular seasons due to it - I understand it and would never climb then. In theory, if in a particular place even a single climb whichever time of the year, no matter how careful I would tread, could make irreversible damage to environment, that would perhaps be the only case I would refrain from climbing a mountain at all.
In some cases however, environmental regulations are a fig leaf for e.g. guiding companies blatantly making money, etc. I know such cases in Europe.
To sum up... In most of the cases above, having the resources and skills I would climb a particular mountain but keep a low profile. The more sensitive the issue, the less I would spray about it, simply not to make life harder for prospective climbers. There are some degrees to it:
E.g. I openly write in my TRs about not-so-legally crossing state borders in the Balkans, where regulations are vague and it's difficult to determine the current state of affairs, just to inform the community what they can expect. The pros outweigh the cons here.
'Off-limit private mountains' - what a disgusting concept! First I would negotiate to enter legally - I respect the landowners who respect climbers. If that was impossible I would quietly sneak in. Playing hide-and-seek with some gun-wielding farmers and rent-a-cops would be part of the fun. I would keep a low profile afterwards, not to make life harder for other climbers. I would gladly join a public campaign against those mountains being closed.
Having the possibility to climb e.g. Ship Rock, I would attempt it. Would keep a much lower profile than the authors of this TR though. In SP, I would maybe just post a few pics, make some vague references. Would tell my friends over a beer, and that's it. Out of respect for Navajo beliefs. In my own system of values, I can pay tribute to the mountain by climbing it, instead of 'conquering' it (there's no such thing to me!) but others may feel differently. BTW, good points raised by Klenke a few posts above. Still I give 10/10 for the story...
I understand the temptation to post such a TR, would feel it myself!
Had I the resources and skills to climb e.g. Kailash, I might go for it, hypothetically. If it's ever possible not to be seen. Maybe I would tell someone many years later, or maybe not :)
I might have gone over the top in some points, but that was on purpose, try to get my point...

lcarreau

lcarreau - Dec 6, 2010 8:29 am - Voted 1/10

Re: off-limit mountains

You say you have a deep respect for religion, but would STILL
climb the landform ??? ??

Sorry, but I don't understand your (somewhat selfish) way of thinking.

You have to be a native American to understand what's going on here. I'm NOT a native American, but I have a right to express
my feelings and views, being a part of Society and all.

Please.. don't climb the mountain!

kamil

kamil - Dec 6, 2010 8:39 am - Voted 10/10

Re: off-limit mountains

Larry, I'll most probably never climb this mountain cos I live in another continent and if I make it to America I'll have other priorities...
I wrote above that for me climbing a mountain is a way of paying my tribute to it, not conquering it. I know others may have completely different feelings in this matter and I respect it, so if I ever climb a 'sacred' mountain, I'll try to refrain from spraying and bragging too openly about it.
Cheers,
Kamil

lcarreau

lcarreau - Dec 6, 2010 8:55 am - Voted 1/10

Re: off-limit mountains

Thanks, but "these guys" sound like they're in the business of
conquering it rather than paying tribute to it. Guess I could be
wrong, but that's the message I'm getting..

History repeats itself. The native Americans were "conquered" in
the name of new land.

NOW, the LAND is being conquered, in the name of new Americans!

Dmitry Pruss

Dmitry Pruss - Dec 6, 2010 10:37 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Religion is different

How is it different from any other landowner? Why should they be allowed to regulate conduct of non-members outside of their churches and halls?

The tribal faiths may be the last line of defense of the tribes, but they are also a convenient way to make the victims of colonial injustice content with their fate, and they are also a way a way to channel the people's sense of injustice into a form of xenophobia ... to vent their anger towards those who are simply not like them, while protecting their true oppressors.

The more controlling power one cedes to a religion, the less is this faith worth being respected. Render Caesar's unto Caesar, remember?

KujoA2

KujoA2 - Dec 6, 2010 9:46 am - Hasn't voted

Article?

This was a good read, but I'd rather have seen an article on the front page discussing crags or mountains that are currently banned or on the fence, and what's being done for access, and what climbers can do to maintain access. (Respecting no-climb areas, or posting great reports about inspiring peaks, such as this one.) I'm reminded of the voluntary June climbing restriction on Devil's Tower.

Even if the place does have great climbing history, the FA was in what, 1939? I think the Navajo have you beat in the history category.

A-Lex

A-Lex - Dec 6, 2010 12:57 pm - Hasn't voted

Wow...

I am not stoked on your send guys. I have met both of you, and I thought well of you before I read this. But, this is just plain disrespectful to the Navajo Nation and its people and certainly changes my opinions of y’all.

At least on the front page this raises the issue of access, which is damn important for climbers to address. So in that regard thanks for posting this.

-Alex

A-Lex

A-Lex - Dec 6, 2010 1:23 pm - Hasn't voted

Re: Wow...

Yeah not much more to say. I'm not trippin horribly - I just would have made other decisions is all. I doubt that I would see it differently sitting around the family night table though...anyway - keep climbing - just climb non-culturally significant sh*t!

A-Lex

A-Lex - Dec 6, 2010 2:00 pm - Hasn't voted

Re: Wow...

Yeah I am beginning to understand yours more as well. I still would not have climbed that thing, but I appreciate that it does appear some thought went into it. I would have been stoked if you guys mentioned talking to the elders and getting their approval! I have found that some of my interactions with Indians have been as rewarding as some of the climbs I've done.

mrchad9

mrchad9 - Dec 6, 2010 1:30 pm - Voted 10/10

Great Adventure

I'm happy for the controversy over this one. I don't usually read trip reports, prefer to go on my own outings more, suppose I am selfish. But hearing rumblings I decided to give it a read and glad I did.

Sounds like an awesome trip and and memorable experience you will have the rest of your life, and your story had me from beginning to end. I see no reason for any regrets. No one was hurt, stolen from, abused, blah blah. The tribes will be fine. And your photos are spectacular.

Viewing: 21-40 of 66

Parents 

Parents

Parents refers to a larger category under which an object falls. For example, theAconcagua mountain page has the 'Aconcagua Group' and the 'Seven Summits' asparents and is a parent itself to many routes, photos, and Trip Reports.

Ship RockTrip Reports