McClellan Butte Comments
[ Post a Comment ]
|
| Charlie | Untitled Comment | |
Voted 8/10 | Good route description. | |
| Posted Feb 10, 2002 10:18 pm | ||
| Scott | Untitled Comment | |
Voted 10/10 | Looks better. I agree about the route page. | |
| Posted Apr 18, 2004 10:06 pm | ||
| Fred Spicker | Untitled Comment | |
Hasn't voted | Edit June 5 - Jeffrey, Much improved - thank you for taking it on. Suggestion: It seems to me that much of what is in the Overview would be more appropriate for a Route Page | |
| Posted Mar 6, 2005 8:25 am | ||
| wildstar | Untitled Comment | |
Voted 10/10 | I agree with the previous comments. | |
| Posted Mar 26, 2005 10:31 pm | ||
| zoroastr | Untitled Comment | |
Voted 8/10 | I can't see anything wrong with this page. Granted, the peak is not given the treament you'd expect for a major climb, but then, McClellan's Butte is a minor bump along the I-90 freeway, NOT a Himalayan giant. The page adequately directs interested parties to the peak, gives sufficient details about the trail, and even includes some nice images. I don't go to Star Wars expecting to see Dr. Zhivago, and I don't expect the authors of short hike trip reports to bore me with excruciating details that are all out of proportion to the thing being described. Fine page. | |
| Posted Jun 3, 2005 10:12 am | ||
 | ||
| Derek Franzen | Untitled Comment | |
Voted 10/10 | This page has just been adopted by the current maintainer. Most of the comments (and votes) from below are for the state of the page by the last maintainer. | |
| Posted Jun 3, 2005 7:23 pm | ||
| Derek Franzen | Untitled Comment | |
Voted 10/10 | I like the photos you've added; thanks for improving this page. You might edit the overview section (paragraphs) and include just the interesting points about the peak there (my personal preference). All in all a good page. | |
| Posted Jun 3, 2005 7:24 pm | ||
| ||
| Jeffrey Zickert | Untitled Comment | |
Hasn't voted | Thankyou for your support. I will visit McClellan's Butte again soon and hope to have some new pictures to post. | |
| Posted Jun 5, 2005 12:50 pm | ||
| osatrik | Spring variation | |
Voted 7/10 | During the spring and winter you can cut off the large loop to the south by going up the steep avalanche gully if you are comfortable on steep (up to 45 degree) snow and alpine ice. Makes a great spring alpine climb when the conditions are good. | |
| Posted Aug 26, 2006 4:42 pm | ||
| Redwic | New Page Owner | |
Hasn't voted | I have just adopted the McClellan Butte page. It was in desperate need of improvement, and had gone nearly four years without needed improvements (during which timeframe the trail itself even changed). The GPS coordinates were wrong, the county was missing, the driving directions were vague, and the trail description was defunct. If anyone else has any suggestions for the page, please let me know. | |
| Posted Aug 20, 2009 12:13 am | ||
|