I agree it's a fine addition. Where you say that the ascent is pretty easy and then that in summer it's rated T5, these two statements don't match. T5 is already a quite demanding hike up (but a very easy climb, of course).
Thank you for your comment Vid. It's not very consistant to define T5 as an easy hike. I'm used to define everything easier than L/F (climbing grade) as easy, but that doesn't mean that T5 is an easy hike. Good to know that there are SP members wich notice this kind of inconsistent claims.
Yes. My point was that if a climber would read it, everything would be ok - ascent is easy. A hiker might write you back: "I went up with my daughter and grandma and it was not so easy for them. It's good that you wrote T5, but in the text you could perhaps say a bit more to whom it is easy ;)
Isn't an idea to put a regular warning at every post? Something to warn readers that pages are made by volunteers (not allways experts) and that information can be subjective.
EricChu - Apr 20, 2010 2:03 pm - Voted 10/10
Thanks for posting this page!It's so nice to see some Graubünden on SummitPost!
Jurgen - Apr 20, 2010 2:29 pm - Hasn't voted
Re: Thanks for posting this page!You're welcome. I hope more people will add some mountains in the Graubünden canton.
Vid Pogachnik - Apr 21, 2010 2:08 pm - Voted 10/10
Re: Thanks for posting this page!I agree it's a fine addition. Where you say that the ascent is pretty easy and then that in summer it's rated T5, these two statements don't match. T5 is already a quite demanding hike up (but a very easy climb, of course).
Jurgen - Apr 21, 2010 2:41 pm - Hasn't voted
Re: Thanks for posting this page!Thank you for your comment Vid. It's not very consistant to define T5 as an easy hike. I'm used to define everything easier than L/F (climbing grade) as easy, but that doesn't mean that T5 is an easy hike. Good to know that there are SP members wich notice this kind of inconsistent claims.
Vid Pogachnik - Apr 21, 2010 3:58 pm - Voted 10/10
Re: Thanks for posting this page!Yes. My point was that if a climber would read it, everything would be ok - ascent is easy. A hiker might write you back: "I went up with my daughter and grandma and it was not so easy for them. It's good that you wrote T5, but in the text you could perhaps say a bit more to whom it is easy ;)
Cheers!
Vid
Jurgen - Apr 22, 2010 1:33 pm - Hasn't voted
Re: Thanks for posting this page!Isn't an idea to put a regular warning at every post? Something to warn readers that pages are made by volunteers (not allways experts) and that information can be subjective.
Cheers, Jurgen