by brenta » Tue Aug 07, 2012 5:59 am
I second the Navajo suggestion, but propose Niwot ridge for the approach. Airplane Gully is interesting, but going both up and down is too much scree for my taste. Plus, Niwot Ridge is the best ridge scramble in the Indian Peaks. Paiute via the southeast ridge of Audubon is also very nice. The north ridge of Neva and the traverse from South to North Arapaho are too. In the the Middle Saint Vrain drainage, Elks Tooth and Ogalalla are certainly off the beaten path.
Crater Lake is really pretty. Both times I've climbed Lone Eagle I approached it from the west, and it was great, but I believe going over Pawnee Pass would be equally scenic and only moderately more strenuous. In fact, crossing the Divide at Buchanan Pass and coming back via Pawnee Pass is considered a great tour of the Indian Peaks. Average people do it as a multi-day trip.