mrchad9 wrote:Respectfully Fletch... this isn't about being a good or bad climber.
I'm certainly not trying to start a shit storm here, but I sort of think this can be both. I think it is to some degree. I think we would all agree that a half ass page by a good climber is probably a better resource than a good page by a terrible climber, or worse, someone who has never climbed it (or the route in question).
My earlier post was just meant to point out that I think Brian Kalet can be a very strong contributor (I know he is on other sites and I believe he was here in the past). Therefore, it's really a matter of desire more than ability. There may be other solutions here. Him wanting to hoard the pages for ego reasons is one i'm having a hard time believing... maybe he's just busy...
However, in all fairness, it sounds like you've tried the diplomatic approach and that didn't work. If so, then carry on. I'm supportive of your suggestions...