Khan Tengri Additions and Corrections
[ Post an Addition or Correction ]
|Finally a new maintainer.|
I vote ten already, as I know the result will be great.
If I were you, I would detach all the routes which are now attached to the page. I can't judge the quality of them as I haven't climbed them. The submitter hasn't climbed any of them either and telling from his other route submissions they are at best misleading and potentially dangerous.
|Posted Feb 2, 2007 9:42 am|
|Thanks. Yes, I will detach them if need be! I'll have a read of those routes this weekend and see what I make of them.|
|Posted Feb 2, 2007 1:58 pm|
|Posted Feb 3, 2007 6:24 pm|
|zoomloco||Harder than the page lets on|
|The Khan Tengri main page currently (July 16 2011) states:|
"Khan Tengri is generally considered to be the third hardest Snow Leopard mountain after Pik Lenin and Pik Kommunizma."
This statement is misleading and almost certainly incorrect. Lenin is well known as one of the easiest 7000m peaks in the world, and it is also well established that Pik Pobeda is the most difficult Snow Leopard peak.
But the general interpretation of the quote would mean both Lenin and Kommunism are more difficult than Khan and Pobeda, which is simply, and in the eyes of everyone who has climbed those peaks, false. There may be some quibbling in the ordering of the middle three peaks, but those at the easiest (Lenin) and hardest (Pobeda) are very well established. The truth is that Lenin and Khorzhenevskaya are definitely easier, but that is not how the page is worded.
A more accurate statement would be " Khan Tengri is generally considered to be the second hardest snow leopard peak after Pik Pobeda," which is true and clear. Some think Kommunism is harder than Khan because of the altitude. But there is no way Lenin is more difficult.
|Posted Jul 16, 2011 3:59 pm|
|BigLee||Re: Harder than the page lets on|
|That was a typo error. Should have said Pobeda and Kummunizma|
|Posted Aug 6, 2011 5:21 pm|