I have these for myself and I'm very very pleased with them! Absolutely waterproof ánd absolutely water-resisting. I've been with them in the Italian Alps and the German mid-mountains. They proved to be very usefull and not to expensive.
The cut and shape is ok. But when it comes to materials this product is not designed so well. Upper part is made of a sof material which can be penetrated by crampons easely. So I have to duct-tape the inside over and over again.