dshankar wrote:Is Clouds Rest really easier? While Dana is a 3k ft gain and a 5-6 mile round trip, Clouds Rest looks like a beast with a 14 mile roundtrip and an equally impressive 10k ft summit. I feel like arriving the night before & acclimating at the trailhead with a full night's sleep in the car before climbing Dana in the morning would be easier than a 14 mile day hike. I imagine Clouds Rest also takes longer than the ~6-7 hour Dana roundtrip?
Edit: I'm also not overly concerned with summiting. If the weather goes bad or I'm having a tough time, I'll certainly call it a day and head down!
You are correct that the Dana round trip is less than half the distance, but it is steep, and all at high elevation. The higher you go, the harder it gets. The steeper you go, the harder it gets. If you are able to get a good night of sleep in your car and then respond well to the altitude, it should be quick and easy if you are in decent shape. You may even want to take in the views atop Lembert Dome before heading home, assuming all goes well, including weather. When I was faster, my round trip hike of Dana took less than 3 hours, including 15 minutes on the summit. That was after more than 24 hours at Tuolomne Meadows. That is also the best I've felt going above 13k. When coming from sea level, I tend to notice altitude at around 10k and feel progressively worse the higher I go past 12k. I have only felt miserable from developing AMS once, from 13-14k. I felt fine again when dropping back below 12-13k.
The unknown is how you will feel at high altitude. The lower suggestions are lower risk as far as fatigue from altitude and steepness, as well as lower risk of AMS. They are also arguably more scenic. If the altitude hits you hard on Dana, but not a little lower, the longer mileage, but lower altitude suggestions could end up feeling much easier. The suggestions of caution and moderation from many of us are because altitude can cause miserable and even deadly reactions at lower elevations than many might expect. It is easy to become dehydrated up high as well. If you feel good below 10k, the rolling 14 miles to Clouds Rest and back should not take more than 7 hours, but I'm not sure of your pace and endurance.
Have a good time. If it goes well, I'm sure you can get many additional ideas or suggestions on SP. I have some places with more solitude in mind, but the beauty of the area you will be visiting is top notch.