Pirineos: Prepirineos Aragoneses Additions and Corrections

Viewing: 1-19 of 19
visentin

visentin - Mar 12, 2009 9:22 am - Voted 10/10

"Pre-Pirineos"

I would rather translate it into english, but besides, I don't find this term very convenient. Pre-Pyrenees can be on both sides. Why dont' you name it simply "Huesca" ?

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Mar 13, 2009 11:32 am - Hasn't voted

Re:

yes, really pre-Pyrenees exist in a lot of parts in both sides of the range but the most important books call this area Pre pirineos of Huesca, it's a term according with the texts as for example "Pirineos 1000 ascensiones" from Miguel Angulo, the Bible of Pyrenees. The reason of the name Pre-Pirineos is the location of some important ranges in this zona specially the Sierra de Guara. It's not exist a range like this in all the Pre-Pyrenees on both sides, but I writed Huesca to identificate the area because it's true that exist a lot of Pre-Pirineos. If you write only Huesca you must include the South Part of Huesca and this area don't have any interest, only the Pre-Pirineos are interesting with nice peaks and beautifull images of nearby Pyrenees, and the North part (Pyrenees). The North part of Huesca is including in every area as Canfranc, tena, Ordesa, Benasque.... it's not a good idea to repeat. All the people in the North of Spain known the term Pre-Pirineos de Huesca, but why?... I don´t know, I only climb mountains, I think is a term only to clasifie these mountains in a chapter probably and don't write Riglos-Guara-Loarre ranges. Why the people don't call Montserrat and Montseny the Pre-Pirineos of Catalonya?... I dont't know, it's only the use of words for the people for years. The chapter of books about the pre-pirineos of my province (Navarra) call this mountains "the Navarre watchtowers of South of Pyrenees", it's only the need of a title, really is not very important, it's a excuse to write about some mountains that's not located in Pyrenees at 100% in some books and webs about Pyrenees. Do you understand me? (my english is not very good but I try to learn)

visentin

visentin - Mar 13, 2009 12:04 pm - Voted 10/10

Re: Re:

I do understand you, if you say that this expression is common from the spannish point of view it's OK, but we should always keep in mind that the Pyrenees lie on 2 countries, not only the one from which we describe the mountains... I browsed from time to time the pages about the Pyrenees and there are too many spannish titles in my opinion...
Same with the polish who write slovak peaks names in polish orthograph only, and so on..

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Mar 15, 2009 5:53 pm - Hasn't voted

Re: Re:

It's normal, 99% of pages of Pyrenees on SP has a Spanish writer, if you kwon French people to join to summitpost to write pages I'll be happy with it, but all my maps and books are in Spanish and I'm Spanish and for this reason a lot of mountains of SP are in Spanish side of Pyrenees and appear with the Spanish name. The people that write me demanding information normally are Europeans (not French) and Spanish. I don't know the reason but the French mountaineers don't write pages about their side of the range. I try to keep the original name and not the translation name. In the border mountains I use normally the most popular name, for example Le Taillon appear with the name Punta Negra in a lot of Spanish maps but all the mountaineers of both sides call "Taillon" this peak. Another examples of mountains that I don't write the Spanish name: Balaitous (Pico Moros in Spanish maps) or Pallas (Palas in Spanish), Vignemale (Viñamala o Comachibosa in Spanish). Do you try to find with both names? in my mountains in the query name generally are both but not in the title, I don't like the names Punta Negra or Pico Moros. If you find a peak with most popular name in French you can write to me. I love the French Pyrenees but the Spanish side is nearby of my home. I will wish to climb and write pages about Mount Valier, Maubermé, ... and more peaks of French side but they're far from my home to visit in a week-end.

visentin

visentin - Mar 16, 2009 3:44 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Re:

Hello Rafa,

I understand perfectly your point of view, and I am ashamed that so few french people made pages about the french side of the Pyrenees. I fully agree with your philosophy of keeping spannish peaks names in spannish, french peaks names in french, and both names for those which lie on the border. Every time I have a remark about a bilingual peak name I will let you know, and same if you have a doubt.
I'm indeed thinking about starting pages about french peaks of the Pyrenees, mostly in the Vallée d'Aure area. The other day I made a summary of all peaks I climbed and which don't have a SP page. I might start with the top 10 (most importants), probably the first 3 will be Hourgade, Turon and Bastan :
http://www.summitpost.org/custom-object/456100/Pyrenees-peaks-without-SP-page.html
I dont' know if I will ever make all of them on SP, especially the small ones in the end, but I might do a bit those in the middle section. Let me know which ones are in your opinion the most significant so I can make them first. It will also depend on the documentation I have now, because I am living now out of France and I left most books there, I just have very few maps...

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Mar 17, 2009 6:35 am - Hasn't voted

Re: Re:

thanks for your work and the list

-Estaragne has a page, I writed it long time ago, you can delete it.
-Ansabére is called Petretxema in Spanish and has a page of my friend eza. It's a popular name even in French side and French books. Both names are correct.

From your list are very important as well Arbizon and Clarabide

I climbed from the list:
Peña de las Once
Turbón
Tuc del Port de Vielha

I'll write some day the pages of this peak but my list of mountains without page in SP probably have more than 300 peaks, only in Pyrenees. My priority for the moment (probably, but my english is not good and I write slowly): Tendeñera, Turbón, Montcalm,... but I climbed a lot of mountains out of Pyrenees as well, it's difficult to choose the next to write. Another problem are the pages of sub-ranges, nobody help me with it, the people only want to write about peaks, but it's neccesary to include the peak in an area. I you undestand some of Spanish language you can visit: www.mendikat.net with a lot of information about mountains of Spanish and French Pyrenees. I'll write more pages there, it's most prioritary to me to write the pages for the Spanish people than for SP in this moment.

visentin

visentin - Mar 17, 2009 7:21 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Re:

Thanks for the feedback. Exact, I didn't notice Estaragne. Pétragène and Ansabère are not the same peak, despite close to each other. Petragène, for the french, is located nearer the Mail de Acherito, on the left when you arrive at the border from France. But it lies in the shaddow of Ansabère and in my opinion does not deserve a page.
As for the subranges you are right, it's a big work to define everything alone. If I were you I wouldn't have defined the french side by regions (bearn, bigorre), but by subranges. I would have done for example the Néouvielle as an area/range, but it is included in teh (too wide) Bigorre. Perhaps if one day there are enough items I'll make a sub-sub-range for the Néouvielle.
Tendeñera is gorgeous, I'm waiting impatiently for your page. I haven't been on Montcalm. For Turbón, I haven't walked the whole ridge the page made by you will probably be better. But as I told you I will start with some french ones in priority. Arbizon sounds a good idea for a start...

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Mar 18, 2009 4:21 am - Hasn't voted

Re: Re:

I climbed almost all the peaks over 2000m of Valley of Belagua (except one), and it's include Petragème. In Spanish side we called this peak Sobarcal, it's a nice peak as well. Ansabère is called Petretxema and it's include the famous aiguilles, North and South (only for rock-climbers, not for me). One of my favourite peaks is the small Petit Pic d'Ansabère, but it don't has interest for SP. Links (text in Spanish) to pages of this peaks:
Petretxema/Ansabere
Petit Pic d'Ansabere
Sobarcal/Petrageme

really the true summit of peak Ansabère is the Aiguille North, but for the normal mountaineers is almost impossible a rock climb of 6b. Many people think that Ansabère is only the aiguille and the Spanish summit is Petretxema... for me both names are o.k.

Tendeñera in Spanish for the moment, ..bufff I have a lot of text to traslate to English in this important peak, specially because the routes are long... be patient with me!

visentin

visentin - Jan 19, 2011 9:21 am - Voted 10/10

Re: Re:

Rafa, what do you think about sharing this page with "Ojo" (Jane). She has posted really a lot of mountains lately in this area, with beautiful pages. She looks like the right person dont you think ? ;)

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Jan 19, 2011 10:57 am - Hasn't voted

Re: Re:

yes, it's a good idea. I added ojo as admin of the page of Prepirineos Aragoneses. I think that Cuculo and Pusilibro are very interesting peaks but I didn't have time to write the pages and for me it's perfect to add only the pictures. It was a great idea to create this page of the range because the area is very interesting and she can show these nice peaks but the text is very poor because I hate to write about the areas but it's necessary to add the mountain/rocks in the future.

ojo - Jan 19, 2011 12:32 pm - Hasn't voted

re: pre...

Hi there. I've been thinking about the term "pre-Pyrenees" and really... ¿is Pusilibro & Gratal pre-- or PRE-pre?? or ... "Hoya de Huesca"... ? I've been playing around with a page about "Parque Natural de la Sierra y Cañones de Guara" too as its a significant area. Sadly, I don't have a lot of info about the climbing and canyoning there (Mascún, Vadiello, Rodellar etc). Rafa, what do you mean when you write: "I hate to write about the areas?" For me, I've enjoyed doing these recent pages cos I love this place. I don't have your experience (you and Eric both)! - only 3 years living here. They're only "peaklets" as Eric calls them! :) but in my eyes the area is so worth telling folk about. Thanks for admin access. It will be fun to try to expand the page --- but with your help, please!

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Jan 19, 2011 1:33 pm - Hasn't voted

Re: re: pre...

thanks ojo, you always will have my help, I wrote the page but the page need a little more, it's very short. Write something if you want or don't write but I feel that you love the area and you want to write more. I love the peaks as Tozal de Guara, Pusilibro, Cuculo, Gratal, Oturia,... I love to show the peaks but the areas are only the way to show the peaks for me and it's a problem when I want to write more peaks and the area don't appears in SP. I begun with the area because whitout it we don't have information about this interesting place but I prefer to use my time to write the peaks. I specially love to show images and don't write anything, ... it's perfect when somebody write the page and I only add the pictures.

Prepirineos Aragoneses,... uff, we need some area to link this peaks, for me it's a very good name, it's the better name... if the catalonian people write more peaks in the future we will think about the name, but the catalonian people prefer Sub-Pyrenees (Subpirineu in catalonian language)... the people is strange and a little crazy, they used different names to make difficult the work of the authors of webs about mountains,he,he,he

links:
Sub-Pyrenees
Pre-Pyrenees
Geology of Pyrenees

The future:
Pre-pyrenees of Navarre? I think not, it's my home but nobody use Pre-Pyrenees, it's very near of Pyrenees and we will include in Baztan, Roncesvalles.... (areas of Pyrenees). The only range will be Sierra de Leire and I love it but I think it's not interesting for SP for the moment.

Pre-Pyrenees of Catalonya of Sub-pyrenees: when the peaks appear we will need, not for the moment.

Catalan pre-costal ranges: Montseny and Montserrat are interesting but we don't need another range. The web of Montserrat is good and we will need maybe a page about Montseny but it's not always necessary to add more areas without utility.

visentin

visentin - Jan 20, 2011 2:33 am - Voted 10/10

Re: re: pre...

What a complicated geography ! :)
I think the current name is not bad, from the moment the Catalan and Navarre Pre-Pyrenees might also exist one day. Montserrat is worth remaining as a single area by itself, given the amount of rock-climbing routes which is a specific discipline.
By the way, Rafa, I know they are not 100% related to the Pyrenees, but why not attaching the Montserrat, Bardenas, the Basque Mountains, Aralar (Txindoki is sometimes mentionned in Pyrenees guidebooks).
Of course the last 2 are also a part of the beginning of the Cantabric mountains, the main advantage would be to increase the visibility of these pages on SP.
I don't know if you have seen it also, I made an "album" for all the remaining part of the Eastern Pyrenees to "fill" the last gap. It is not very official, but it can serve as a ressource of images if one day the area (or more areas from it) are created.

ojo - Jan 20, 2011 3:32 am - Hasn't voted

I found...

..this morning my map Editorial Pirieno calls Parque Sierra de Guara "Sierras Exteriores"....

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Jan 20, 2011 4:23 pm - Hasn't voted

Re: I found...

do you know the map and book of editorial sua?
Sierra de Guara
it's very interesting

ojo - Jan 21, 2011 3:59 am - Hasn't voted

Re: I found...

Ah. No I don't. I know of "sua" but not this. A recent publication. Possibly worth checking out.

ojo - Jan 20, 2011 3:40 am - Hasn't voted

oh, and a question...

... what constitutes a peak that "has interest for SP"? This is a serious question.
I realise I've just written my pages because they interest me - and if they get some votes, that's all good. Maybe the main emphasis here is big peaks, mountaineering and not so much on rambles and hikes. But maybe I should be thinking of SP globally and ... well, what to write about and what not. Any advice?

Rafa Bartolome

Rafa Bartolome - Jan 20, 2011 10:48 am - Hasn't voted

Re: oh, and a question...

yes it's a very good question. The Spanish mountaineers have a lot of information about mountains in internet in pages as mendikat, mendiak, pirineos3000...they don't need the information in english . I think in SP as a reference if you live in another country (Europe, America,..) and you make a trip (holiday, work,...) in a new area and you need to know the mountains around a zone (in this case Spain). Your target is not the Spanish mountaineers. I think in different people: hikers, climbers, rock-climbers... and according with that I choose the peaks.
Examples: if you need to travel to Bilbao for work you can see in SP some mountains around like Gorbea, Anboto or Txindoki to use the travel to enjoy of the mountains in your free day. The peaks are beautiful and the natural enviroment is nice. It's enough. If you travel to Huesca or Zaragoza you need a nice turistic place like castle of Loarre with the peak Pusilibro (it's perfect) or Sierra de Guara with nice canyons. If you travel only to climb mountains probably you're a mountaineer and you need information about the big peaks of Pyrenees. In my opinion the question is: What kind of mountain can enjoy a person in a little trip in our zone? What mountain can you enjoy if you travel to Huesca for a few of days?... and no more, I think that Riglos, Guara or Loarre are interesting but it's different the election of the peak for a trip of two days in comparation with you that live all the year in the area. You must choose the peaks most important or most beautiful and not all the peaks. It's my opinion but you can write the peaks that you want... it's free. We travelled to Slovenia the last year and we climbed the peaks of SP (it's impossible to read slovenian pages) and the people who travel to Spain can read your desciptions ans see your pictures and NOT ALL THE PEOPLE ARE GREAT MOUNTAINEERS, a lot of hikers visit our country. We need different kind of mountains to show the area.

ojo - Jan 21, 2011 3:47 am - Hasn't voted

Re: oh, and a question...

Thanks for that. I knew that this is not for Spanish mountaineers or hikers. (My "local" site is Pirineos3000.com which is just perfect for me to see what's going on and learn something too). I guess I should re-evalauate what I'm doing here on SP and not just post little peaks that not even folk here do much!


What Spanish areas/mountains in your opinion are still waiting to be written up for SP?


Viewing: 1-19 of 19
Return to 'Pirineos: Prepirineos Aragoneses' main page