TEMPLE CRAG, Moon Goddess Arete, In Winter

TEMPLE CRAG, Moon Goddess Arete, In Winter

Page Type Page Type: Trip Report
Date Date Climbed/Hiked: Mar 19, 2010
Activities Activities: Trad Climbing
Seasons Season: Winter
Some 25 years ago, Miguel Carmona and I (Alois Smrz) attempted the Swiss Arete on Mt. Sill in winter. While skiing by Temple Crag, I had the foolish notion of mentioning the Moon Goddess Arete as yet another possibility for a winter climb. We dismissed the idea right there and it remained just another crazy thought which would never see the time of day. But about three years ago, Miguel brought up the climb again. The approach was reasonable, we knew the route from climbing it in the summer and if the conditions were absolutely perfect, we could attempt it. So for the last three years in the winter months, we have been eyeing the weather, packing and unpacking gear and failing to anticipate the perfect weather window. Every year this mad idea seemed further from coming to fruition. It was with some desperation, that we finally decided to just go for it last week.
Moon Goddess Arete in Winter Miguel Carmona (L) and I starting from Glacier Lodge Road 3-18-2010.
Penelope May kindly helped us with our heavy carry to the Third Lake and from there Miguel and I started at 4 AM on March 19, 2010. We had two thin ropes, rock gear, helmets, winter boots and rock shoes, spare heavy gloves each, one pack, slings, harnesses, down jackets, Gore-Tex tops and bottoms, short ice tool and crampons each. Miguel secured some 20 Power Bar Gels for energy and we had one quart of water between us.
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Penelope May carrying our heavy gear below Temple Crag.
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Approaching the Third Lake.
We snow shoed to the base of the route and had to rope up right at the start of the traverse. The snow was unconsolidated, deep and our steps very insecure. The severe wind that was blowing all day made for very cold climbing. We roped 10 pitches just to get to the 1st Tower and reached the Ibrium Tower by 1 PM.
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Miguel at the starting traverse at 6:00 AM
Moon Goddess Arete in winter On the initial ridge below the 1st Tower
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Mixed rock with a couple of long snow fields
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Full winter conditions and a strong wind on the Arete
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Still low on the Arete but finally on dry rock
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Climbing up to the 1st Tower
Moon Goddess Arete in winter On the short traverse to the base of the 1st Tower
Moon Goddess Arete in winter The 1st Tower traverse
There, prudent thinking could have dictated a quick retreat, but we both felt we needed to keep going. Another 6 pitches of good rock got us to the short rappel at about 7:30 PM. The daylight was gone at this point. Two large towers above us remained to be climbed in the total darkness of a moonless night. Miguel did some outstanding work, weaving his way up the towers illuminated by his headlamp while I struggled with the technical terrain and the 25lb. pack. We reached the top of the route at 11 PM some 17 hours after we started climbing. The steep snow field dropping down to Contact Pass was frozen with sections of a deep and unconsolidated snow. It took us hours to down climb it. Finding the elusive and tiny rap anchors in a sea of snow and rocks just above Contact Pass was our goal. We belayed the last 300 feet or so of the steep mixed terrain. With Miguel’s good memory, a lot of searching, and some luck, we found the rap anchors, down climbed to them and then spent what seemed like an eternity setting up the rap. The wind was so bad that our ropes kept flying all over the wall and the tangled mess made us re-do the set up several times.
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Miguel is climbing up to the Ibrium Tower
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Miguel on the crux 5.8 section of the Ibrium Tower
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Looking down the start of the key section of the Ibrium Tower
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Miguel starting the Tower traverse
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Climbing back up to the Arete
Moon Goddess Arete in winter The last few moves to reach the Arete
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Miguel leading below the crest of the Arete
But eventually, we rapped safely down to the Pass and from there, with crampons and ice axes descended to the Third Lake. We reached our tent at 6 AM Saturday, some 26 hours after we started. All in all, we roped 21 pitches of technical climbing and several hundred feet of roped descent. Penelope, who snow shoed up very early in the morning from Glacier Lodge, thinking that we couldn’t have gone up there in the horrible wind, woke us up with much appreciated offers of food but unfortunately after only three hours of hard sleep.
Moon Goddess Arete in winter We must have done something worthwhile to end up looking like this.
After snowshoeing down to the end of the road by Glacier Lodge, an afternoon was spent there by our vehicles chatting happily and consuming incredible quantities of food, coffee and fruits. Thank you Miguel and Penelope for yet another marvelous trip. This could be the First Winter Ascent of the route. I don’t know of anyone who climbed the route in the winter prior to our ascent and the various High Sierra Guidebooks do not show a winter ascent of the route.
Moon Goddess Arete in winter Thank you Penelope, for all your help!


Comments

Post a Comment
Viewing: 21-40 of 42
asmrz

asmrz - Mar 29, 2010 11:15 am - Hasn't voted

RE all the comments

d shorb, Kathy W, Liba Hardekopf, Fort Mental

This post is getting away from me so I will respond this way. Thanks d shorb, Kathy Wing, I read so many of your trips and notes, thanks for your good wishes, Liba Hardekopf I'm what a wickedly funny friend once described as "Cancelled Czech". I lived here too many years to be considered a real one...Fort Mental, wind chill of bellow zero (or worse), nighttime temps in the low teens and steep rock (that will not hold snow) are all signs of California warm weather climbing, don't you know? Shorts and tee shirts will be absolutely de-rigour in about three months.

depclimb

depclimb - Mar 30, 2010 11:18 am - Hasn't voted

Wonderful climb

Congratulations Alois and Miguel, no climb is easy in the winter.

asmrz

asmrz - Mar 30, 2010 11:40 am - Hasn't voted

Re wonderful

Thanks for your congrats, depclimb. Yeh, nothing comes easy in the winter. We are elated to have climbed the route and for me at this stage of my life, I'm very, very happy about it.

granjero

granjero - Mar 30, 2010 1:40 pm - Voted 10/10

Great Effort!

Looks like a wonderful "types 1 and 2" fun day (and night)!

bearbnz

bearbnz - Mar 30, 2010 6:19 pm - Hasn't voted

Excellent

Alois, what a great adventure. Congratulations for taking that on in winter conditions, and coming away successful. I haven't even gotten around to doing it in the summer. Maybe this is the year, your trip report is a great motivator. Great work!

BCB - Mar 30, 2010 7:43 pm - Voted 10/10

Stout!

This is inspiring material to ponder while climbing in the lower valleys and waiting for the - ahem - tamer high Sierra season. Thanks for sharing!

Vicles

Vicles - Mar 31, 2010 4:03 am - Hasn't voted

good effort

Way to get after it! In Jan. 08 Cullen Kirk and I did Sun Ribbon Arete in very similar conditions, 18 hours tent to tent...high wind, loose snow, darkness, cold, etc etc...so I know exactly how you felt (and feel!) How did you keep your water from freezing? Did you melt any snow? 1/2 Qt per person for 26 hours is insane! We both drank at least a quart before our camel backs froze solid...

As far as the first winter ascent of Moon Goddess goes, I dunno...My gut says that it's been done before, but that's just because I was surprised at the list that had been on Sun Ribbon in previous winters before us! A good resource is Doug Robinson...I know he's on Supertopo as DR...

what's next?

asmrz

asmrz - Mar 31, 2010 12:26 pm - Hasn't voted

Re Good effort

Superbum thanks for sharing your experience. A good effort on the Sun Ribbon, a harder and a longer route.

We don't carry camel backs, never have.

We carry wide mouth Nalgene bottles with insulated bottle carriers. In the winter,we start with a hot liquid and add snow to the liquid to extend it a bit. Works well in alpine terrain.

It was so cold on the arete, we hardly drank at all.

I hear you about the FWA, we will find out soon enough. Not that it matters much, an effort with an old climbing buddy and a friend is what this was all about.

What's next?

I have a long list of TO DO things, mostly obscure stuff in the Sierra that we left out of our years of rambling there. Miguel and Joe LeMay are completing yet another new route on the SFLPP, they hope to have it wrapped up by late spring. If I feel well enough physically, I will keep doing this "scrambling thing" for a while longer. What else is there in life?

Marcsoltan

Marcsoltan - Mar 31, 2010 10:22 pm - Voted 10/10

A great TR...

especially when it brings back many memories. Just loved it.
Thank you very much, Alois.

SpiderSavage

SpiderSavage - Apr 1, 2010 12:08 am - Voted 10/10

Bad Ass

Alois, Miguel, Penelope, You guys are nuts! Good work. May you climb forever.

asmrz

asmrz - Apr 1, 2010 11:51 am - Hasn't voted

Re Bad Ass

Hi Chris

It was great climbing with Miguel again. One just cannot overestimate the power of a good partnership in the mountains. A bit harder trip than the last one (Langley North Arete in 1999). We had a ball even if it almost killed me.

Without Pen, this would have never happened. I simply could not carry all of the gear up to Third Lake and as you know Miguel can only carry 20-25 pounds. Pen is a gamer.

Hope all is well with you. Thanks for the kind comments.

asmrz

asmrz - Apr 1, 2010 11:54 am - Hasn't voted

Re A Great TR

Hi Marc
Thanks for the note. I bet you have seen a lot of the Palisades over your "short" climber life. What a place, what wonderful time there for all of us. Cheers bro, Alois.

ChugachMan

ChugachMan - Apr 1, 2010 12:40 pm - Voted 10/10

Nice work!

Nice work Alois and Miguel - enjoyed the great pics and TR.

Craig Peer

Craig Peer - Apr 1, 2010 1:39 pm - Voted 10/10

Wow !

Excellent trip report and a great climb. Too cold for me !

asmrz

asmrz - Apr 1, 2010 2:39 pm - Hasn't voted

Re Nice work

Hey ChugachMan, what's with skiing the Tahquitz Rock North Gully? I saw your tracks there the day after you guys climbed the face. Awesome!Thanks for your note. A.

asmrz

asmrz - Apr 1, 2010 4:52 pm - Hasn't voted

Re Wow!

Hi Mr. Peer, nice to hear from you. Yeh, a bit too cold, but a lot of fun. Cheers bro, Alois.

Blair

Blair - Apr 1, 2010 7:27 pm - Voted 10/10

Great TR

Good on you guys for another great winter ascent! Thanks for sharing and looks like a fun route in winter

asmrz

asmrz - Apr 2, 2010 7:22 pm - Hasn't voted

Re Great TR

Thanks Blair, It sure felt good to be on the rope again with my old friend.

The route is reasonable even in full winter conditions. A lot of it is steep rock, so not too much of the white stuff needs to be run through.

If anyone tries this in winter, just make sure you know where the RAP ANCHORS are above Contact Pass. Finding them is really the crux of the climb!

jvarholak

jvarholak - Apr 2, 2010 11:18 pm - Voted 10/10

Great, Great Form Gentlemen!

the name of the game. congratulations,
john

asmrz

asmrz - Apr 3, 2010 12:04 pm - Hasn't voted

Re Great Form..

Thank you John. More than anything, a hard work to get it done. It took me "a few" days to recover from this little day trip.

Viewing: 21-40 of 42


Parents 

Parents

Parents refers to a larger category under which an object falls. For example, theAconcagua mountain page has the 'Aconcagua Group' and the 'Seven Summits' asparents and is a parent itself to many routes, photos, and Trip Reports.

Temple CragTrip Reports