I don't know that I've climbed enough to say it should NOT be Top 10, but it was a really good day. Climbed with Rom and a large crew. Scrambled over the Fatironette. We didn't see a way to descend to the south gully (Maiden side) - at least it seemed like it would be a hike up a good piece before we could get to it. The descent off the north-side gully seems like the natural way down.
Climbed with Jamie after warming up on The Forgotten Flatiron (aka Icarus), which was my first trad lead. I led most of the Fatiron as well, and found it a bit run out in places, but tree slings came in handy! We both think we ended up too far left on P2 and into the 5.5/6 variation.