Welcome to SP!  -

UN 12819 Comments


[ Post a Comment ]
Viewing: 1-20 of 22 « PREV 1 2 NEXT » 

mtwashingtonmonroeUntitled Comment

mtwashingtonmonroe

Voted 10/10

Nice page!

-Britt
Posted Aug 30, 2005 9:22 am

mountaingazelleUntitled Comment

mountaingazelle

Voted 10/10

Was it named Bighorn Peak because the Bighorn sheep are so plentiful?
Posted Aug 30, 2005 2:49 pm

Midlife MountaineerUntitled Comment

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

Actually this was an unnamed mountain. I named it Bighorn Peak because I saw more bighorn sheep in one place during my descent than I had seen in any other place. Thanks for your vote.
Posted Aug 31, 2005 1:41 am

Gangolf HaubUntitled Comment

Gangolf Haub

Voted 10/10

Bighorn, Corno Grande, Cornon - most of them haven't been named for the sheep but for their appearance. Good Page!
Posted Aug 31, 2005 2:43 am

CoraxUntitled Comment

Corax

Voted 10/10

Nice page!

Posted Aug 31, 2005 10:32 am

nmskimountaineerUntitled Comment

nmskimountaineer

Voted 5/10

Where did you get the name. As far as I know it still is not officially named. The group I ski with call it Sin Nombre (No Name).
Posted Sep 6, 2005 2:06 pm

Midlife MountaineerUntitled Comment

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

You are correct, this mountain is not officially named. I made up the name - you can do that here. Did you give my page a vote of 2 stars because you didn't like the page or because you didn't like the name?
Posted Sep 8, 2005 2:36 am

nmskimountaineerUntitled Comment

nmskimountaineer

Voted 5/10

Probably mostly because of the name. I don't think unnamed peaks should be named arbitrarily, especially when it gets published somewhere like this. I think Unnamed XX,XXX ft, or Point XX,XXX ft is more appropriate.



However, I do believe you incorrectly labeled the parking spot. Did you park near the Bavarian (Willimas Lake Trailhead), or did you really mean to start people at the Bull of the Woods trailhead??



Sorry if I come across as a ass, no disrespect is meant.
Posted Sep 9, 2005 12:54 pm

Midlife MountaineerUntitled Comment

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

I respect your opinion in this matter. Maybe you're right about this, I'll give it some thought. I don't feel strongly about it one way or another. One of the senior SP members told me that if I do a mountain page for an unnamed mountain I can name it what ever I want to. I thought I had to come up with a name. On the one hand I can see how a person might be upset about someone arbitrarily naming a mountain that they have an attachment to. On the other hand, does it really matter?, it's not an official name...it's only for this web site. Interesting debate.
Posted Sep 10, 2005 4:31 pm

Midlife MountaineerUntitled Comment

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

Yes, you're right about the parking lot. I discovered this lot just this past week . I'll correct the route information. thanks
Posted Sep 10, 2005 4:38 pm

nmskimountaineerUntitled Comment

nmskimountaineer

Voted 5/10

Let me get this straight...... You're going to assign an unnamed peak a name, and publish it, to make it less confusing????? OK.......... BTW, I know you're well regarded around here attm, but I don't care if vinnypapa consulted you about a name. That's just what we need, Texans naming mountains in New Mexico. Sorry, but that is my opinion.
Posted Sep 27, 2005 9:42 am

Midlife MountaineerUntitled Comment

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

nmskimountaineer: attm didn't tell me what to name the mountain, he told me TO name it. Read his e-comment a little more carefully and you'll understand why it should be named. If I change the name to what you and your friends call it, would that make everything ok?
Posted Sep 27, 2005 4:16 pm

nmskimountaineerUntitled Comment

nmskimountaineer

Voted 5/10

No, I'm not asking you to change the name of the peak to what we reference it as. That is not my intent. My only intent is to show that unnamed peaks should not be published with names because it can lead to greater confusion.



attm - no need to get so fired up. It is just easy to push your buttons.....
Posted Sep 28, 2005 6:58 pm

nmskimountaineerUntitled Comment

nmskimountaineer

Voted 5/10

BTW - If I was really so jealous, I could trump the published name of this peak by going through the correct governmental agencies.
Posted Sep 28, 2005 7:01 pm

nmskimountaineerUntitled Comment

nmskimountaineer

Voted 5/10

The summit is actually split between Taos Pueblo and Wheeler Wilderness........
Posted Nov 9, 2005 6:07 pm

RyanSUntitled Comment

RyanS

Voted 10/10

Excellent page! I have a few questions....



Is the name Bighorn Peak official?



Also, is it the eighth highest? The list I've seen ranks Bighorn ninth behind these peaks:



Wheeler Peak

Truchas Peak

North Truchas Peak

Point 12,931

Vintrero Benchmark

Lake Fork Peak

Chimayosos Peak

Jicarita Peak
Posted Feb 11, 2006 2:19 pm

Midlife MountaineerRe: Untitled Comment

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

Thanks for your vote. I made the appropriate corrections to the page.
Posted Feb 18, 2006 6:07 am

scotthsubetter late than never

scotthsu

Hasn't voted

i'm a few years late to the debate here, but my opinion is that the title of this page "Bighorn Peak" adds to the confusion. At the very least, I think UN 12819 or PT 12819 should be somewhere in the title for this page, and 12819 should be included as a query tag. I was almost about to create a page for the peak until I ran across this one. (I just put up a TR on skiing its NW slope and wanted to find a parent for it.) In my TR, I mentioned that some locals call the peak Sin Nombre. I must have skied with some of the same people referred to by nmskimountaineer.
Posted Sep 22, 2008 5:44 pm

Midlife MountaineerRe: better late than never

Midlife Mountaineer

Hasn't voted

I believe you are correct. Added UN 12819
Posted Oct 4, 2008 6:26 pm

DrDickiePeak 12819

DrDickie

Hasn't voted

I asked several people around Taos and everyone calls it no name peak. While literary imagination is usually commendable, in this case your precedent could cause confusion. If every climber gave his or her personal name to every unnamed peak, it would become increasingly difficult for those unfamiliar with an area to know what people are talking about.
Posted Aug 5, 2010 9:59 pm

Viewing: 1-20 of 22 « PREV 1 2 NEXT » 
[ Return to 'UN 12819' main page ]